Buddy Holly - Self-Titled (1958) 1st US Mono Pressing CRL 57210 Pinckneyville
  $   100

 


$ 100   (best offer accepted)   Sold For
May 1, 2026 Sold Date
Apr 21, 2026 Start Date
1 Number Of Bids
  USA Country Of Seller
eBay Sold at
 
save auction  

Description

This is a high-quality, authentic 1958 first US pressing of Buddy Holly’s debut solo masterpiece, originally from my personal collection.

Key Details:

Authentic First Press: Catalog CRL 57210 with the rare "no-glasses" cover photograph.

Rare Pressing Plant: Stamped with the "P" in the runout, confirming it was manufactured at Decca’s Pinckneyville, IL plant.

Play Tested: Guaranteed to play through completely. It has been tested with no skips or issues, providing a classic, warm mono listening experience.

Original Insert: Includes the original 1958 inner sleeve, which is rare to find still intact.

Condition: While not mint, both the jacket and the vinyl (wax) are in good, solid shape for their age. The jacket shows typical vintage character and the vinyl has light surface scuffs that do not impact play.

Protection: Ships in a brand-new 2 mil archival-grade poly sleeve to preserve the jacket and vinyl for years to come.

This is a cornerstone piece of rock and roll history, perfect for a collector who values playability and historical authenticity.


**jacket has been doctored on inside with clear tape to prevent any further splitting ** see pics


price rating


My Recently Viewed Auctions

IRON MAIDEN LP The Number of the Beast 1982 Harvest metal IRON MAIDEN LP The Number of the Beast 1982 Harvest metal / $ 32
MILES DAVIS Kind of Blue LP ORIG Columbia DG 6 Eye Label MONO 1AC / 1AA JAZZ MILES DAVIS Kind of Blue LP ORIG Columbia DG 6 Eye Label MONO 1AC / 1AA JAZZ / $ 60
OLIVIA NEWTON JOHN / ELO - XANADU - UK 1980 1st ISSUE LP + POSTCARDS - EX/EX OLIVIA NEWTON JOHN / ELO - XANADU - UK 1980 1st ISSUE LP + POSTCARDS - EX/EX / $ 34
SOUL BROTHERS SIX northern I'll be loving you EXCELLENT listen now SOUL BROTHERS SIX northern I'll be loving you EXCELLENT listen now / $ 41
Stanley Turrentine Wonderland Plays Music Stevie Wonder Japan Promo Vinyl LP New Stanley Turrentine Wonderland Plays Music Stevie Wonder Japan Promo Vinyl LP New / $ 70
SXL 2197 WBG UK ED2 - RICCI - CARMEN FANTASIE, ZIGEUNERWEISEN, HAVANAISE ETC. NM SXL 2197 WBG UK ED2 - RICCI - CARMEN FANTASIE, ZIGEUNERWEISEN, HAVANAISE ETC. NM / $ 465
northern soul MARVIN GAYE Hitch Hike TAMLA DJ listen northern soul MARVIN GAYE Hitch Hike TAMLA DJ listen / $ 30
Dell Vikings - Whispering Bells - TRI London 45-HL-D 8464 - 1957 - Hear It Dell Vikings - Whispering Bells - TRI London 45-HL-D 8464 - 1957 - Hear It / $ 25
The Beatles Sgt Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band vinyl 1967 LP Paul McCartney The Beatles Sgt Peppers Lonely Hearts Club Band vinyl 1967 LP Paul McCartney / $ 33
Ramones – I Wanna Be Your Boyfriend Testpress Ramones – I Wanna Be Your Boyfriend Testpress "7 Single 1997 Mint- Punk Rock / $ 24
PERE UBU: lady from shanghai FIRE 12 PERE UBU: lady from shanghai FIRE 12" LP 33 RPM brand new Sealed in shrink / $ 33
PETER SELLERS AND SOPHIA LOREN - No 3 E.P. 1961 Parlophone GEP 8848 Ex/Nr Mint PETER SELLERS AND SOPHIA LOREN - No 3 E.P. 1961 Parlophone GEP 8848 Ex/Nr Mint / $ 28
Tito Puente Tito Puente "The Willie & Ray Mambo" Latin Mambo 45 Tico Dark Red Wax HEAR / $ 40
Charlie Parker Vol 2 Savoy MG9001 10 Charlie Parker Vol 2 Savoy MG9001 10" LP New Sounds orig master preRVG Miles Diz / $ 74
BEATLES 1994 LTD. BLUE VINYL 45 WHILE MY GUITAR GENTLY WEEPS / BLACKBIRD NEW NR BEATLES 1994 LTD. BLUE VINYL 45 WHILE MY GUITAR GENTLY WEEPS / BLACKBIRD NEW NR / $ 58
Doo-Wop R&B 45 - Cornel Gunter & The Ermines - You Broke My Heart - Loma Doo-Wop R&B 45 - Cornel Gunter & The Ermines - You Broke My Heart - Loma / $ 26
London Grammar - The Greatest Love - Ltd Zoetrope LP Album Blood Records - 2024 London Grammar - The Greatest Love - Ltd Zoetrope LP Album Blood Records - 2024 / $ 52
JOHNNY CASH I Love You Because FRENCH LONDON EP 1960 rare JOHNNY CASH I Love You Because FRENCH LONDON EP 1960 rare / $ 26
ERASURE in concert - 410 LP EX/EX CN 4971/S bbc transcription services 1987 ERASURE in concert - 410 LP EX/EX CN 4971/S bbc transcription services 1987 / $ 20
IRON MAIDEN BRAVE NEW WORLD REMASTERED DOUBLE BLACK VINYL 180G LYRIC INNERS IRON MAIDEN BRAVE NEW WORLD REMASTERED DOUBLE BLACK VINYL 180G LYRIC INNERS / $ 42
Feminist Sweepstakes by Le Tigre (2001) Punk, Rare Vinyl Lp (Dum Girls, Smith) Feminist Sweepstakes by Le Tigre (2001) Punk, Rare Vinyl Lp (Dum Girls, Smith) / $ 28
LAURYN HILL The Miseducation Of 2x LP vinyl 180g Eur 2016 SEALED Fugees/Lauren LAURYN HILL The Miseducation Of 2x LP vinyl 180g Eur 2016 SEALED Fugees/Lauren / $ 32
The Youngbloods Self Titled Vinyl LP Record 1967 Stereo Dynagroove LSP-3724 The Youngbloods Self Titled Vinyl LP Record 1967 Stereo Dynagroove LSP-3724 / $ 30
Los Cadetes de Linares – Tema De La Pelicula Pistoleros Famosos / NORTEÑO / LP Los Cadetes de Linares – Tema De La Pelicula Pistoleros Famosos / NORTEÑO / LP / $ 38
Dave Brubeck Quartet TIME OUT Analogue Productions 200g 33rpm Vinyl LP Sealed Dave Brubeck Quartet TIME OUT Analogue Productions 200g 33rpm Vinyl LP Sealed / $ 79
Iron Maiden - Number of the Beast [Used Very Good Vinyl LP] UK - Impor Iron Maiden - Number of the Beast [Used Very Good Vinyl LP] UK - Impor / $ 21
Ike Turner's Kings Of Rhythm Ike Turner's Kings Of Rhythm "My Love" Doo Wop/R&B 45 Sue Original HEAR / $ 126
JACKIE MCLEAN A Long Drink Of The Blues NEW JAZZ OJC-253 LP SEALED JACKIE MCLEAN A Long Drink Of The Blues NEW JAZZ OJC-253 LP SEALED / $ 28
BONNIE POINTER DEEP INSIDE MY SOUL/ I love to sing to you TMG1184 MOTOWN EX P.C. BONNIE POINTER DEEP INSIDE MY SOUL/ I love to sing to you TMG1184 MOTOWN EX P.C. / $ 25
LYNYRD SKYNYRD LIVE TRIBUTE TOUR 1987 (1988) LP VINY DOUBLE ALBUM MCA RECORDS LYNYRD SKYNYRD LIVE TRIBUTE TOUR 1987 (1988) LP VINY DOUBLE ALBUM MCA RECORDS / $ 25
PAT BROWN The Good Got To Suffer For The Bad on Seven B northern soul 45 HEAR PAT BROWN The Good Got To Suffer For The Bad on Seven B northern soul 45 HEAR / $ 200
2 LIVE CREW AS CLEAN AS THEY WANNA BE LP SEALED US SKYYWALKER VINYL ME SO HORNY 2 LIVE CREW AS CLEAN AS THEY WANNA BE LP SEALED US SKYYWALKER VINYL ME SO HORNY / $ 25


Similar auctions

BUDDY HOLLY LP Self Titled, Coral Records, CRL 57210, Peggy Sue, 1958 1st Album BUDDY HOLLY LP Self Titled, Coral Records, CRL 57210, Peggy Sue, 1958 1st Album / $ 100
Buddy Holly LP Coral 57210 Stamped Matrix Deep Groove Shrink NM/VG++ Buddy Holly LP Coral 57210 Stamped Matrix Deep Groove Shrink NM/VG++ / $ 100
BUDDY HOLLY S/T 1958 CORAL CRL 57210 CANADIAN PRESS VG+ BUDDY HOLLY S/T 1958 CORAL CRL 57210 CANADIAN PRESS VG+ / $ 110
ORIGINAL MONO ROCK & ROLL LP - BUDDY HOLLY - CORAL 57210 - ORIGINAL MONO ROCK & ROLL LP - BUDDY HOLLY - CORAL 57210 - "BUDDY HOLLY" G / $ 100
Buddy Holly Self Titled LP 1958 Coral CRL 57210 1st Press T1/T1 Machine Stamp VG Buddy Holly Self Titled LP 1958 Coral CRL 57210 1st Press T1/T1 Machine Stamp VG / $ 100
Buddy Holly by Buddy Holly, Coral Records CRL 57210 High Fidelity Original 1958 Buddy Holly by Buddy Holly, Coral Records CRL 57210 High Fidelity Original 1958 / $ 94